In both photos, the one that represents the 22 matching cups is in the middle. The one on the right is the vintage replacement that is thicker, slightly pinkish tinted and heavier than the others and the one on the left is the one that is the same as the 22 matching ones but is slightly more opaque (not as crystal clear).
If you are using them indoors, in the evening, I don't believe the differences in the cups would be noticed. It is somewhat noticeable in bright daylight as you can see in the photos. All in all, just a lovely, lightly used vintage set with the genuine Heisey mark that was made somewhere between 1904 and 1957. We are known for our careful packaging and will do all that is humanly possible to get this set to you in pristine condition!The item "Vintage HEISEY Colonial / Puritan Punch Bowl Set with 24 cups, base, glass ladle" is in sale since Sunday, March 20, 2016. This item is in the category "Pottery & Glass\Glass\Glassware\Elegant\Heisey". The seller is "tooleyweedgolf" and is located in Boonsboro, Maryland. This item can be shipped to United States.